My dad suddenly appears in the doorway, "you better get down here, I think this is it" he exclaims and disappears. Tim and I weary from a long night on “death watch” and three weeks of all night shifts watching over him have been taking a break, dozing in the visitors’ lounge.  The fear that he would die on someone else’s watch has been nagging at me from the start.  Now the time had come.  We stagger to our feet and dash down the hall bursting through the room’s double airlock doors.  I sit at his feet on the right side of the bed.  I’m not really sure why but I put my hand on his chest.  My mother holds one hand (as she has done most of the night), Eddie, his partner, the other. My father is at the head of the bed close to his face.  Tim is on the other side of the bed across from me.

The haunting drone of spastic breathing of the past 12 hours, as he lay comatose, is now replaced by what must certainly be the “death rattle”.  In a matter of seconds his chest heaves reflexively, he gasps, pulling his hands out of Eddie’s and my mother’s grasp. His face ashens as the warmth of the human soul departs. His entire body seems to deflate.  Life is leaving him and we collectively cheer him on.  In an instant he is gone yet, surprisingly we are not distraught. In fact I don’t believe any of us even shed a tear.  We had shed many tears over the past weeks, had many close calls, now we were exhausted and numb. The long night, the many years of worry were over. 

My last look at him in that terrible room is from the hallway. His cold lifeless body, once so strong and agile is bathed in sunlight beaming through the window like a spotlight… his final curtain call (oh.. he would not be happy with the hairdo!).  Bravo my dear brother!  Good show!

Over the 13 years since my brother David’s death of AIDS I have been trying to figure out how to talk about it.  From the very moment of my arrival in NYC in early November, until we buried him back home, it was as if I were in some kind of scripted drama, in a movie. Over and over I found myself stepping back and thinking how surreal the given moment was, how vivid, how rich. “This can’t be happening like this” I would think.  My difficultly over the years lie not in coming to grips with the loss but in finding a way to convey what I can honestly say is the most incredible three weeks of my entire life. I’ve never felt so alive; nothing remotely compares, not even the birth of my children. 

What better setting for drama than NYC, hold up with my brother and his friends. Gay men and drama just go together. I had made many a trip to NYC in the years leading up to his death, unfortunately often as the result of some health crisis and had gotten to know many of them quite well.  Spending time with them was like being in an episode of “Seinfeld” and “Will and Grace” all rolled into one, it was a laugh a minute!  The love my brother’s friends had for him was astonishing, particularly that of his best friend Tim.  For me being in this loving open environment was liberating. We laughed, we cried, often it seems in the same breathe. David was in there right along with us (in between visits from our departed grandmother Coles and Marilyn Monroe) laying in bed, blind, fighting for his life cracking jokes and dissing with the best of them.

A week or so earlier he asked Eddie and I to go make funeral arrangements for him, I broke down and lay at his side weeping uncontrolably.  When I composed myself he promptly directed us to pick out a simple casket… “something in mahogany” he said and .. “see if we can get the Judy Garland Room” at Frank Campbell ( the funeral parlor where she was laid out).  We all busted out in laughter!

We were all there for David, to help him come what may. Little did we know that in the process he was helping us, helping us let go of him. 

Nowadays the life and death struggle of AIDS seems very distant from our awareness.  Back in the late 80s and early 90s suffering and death was a regular part of life in the gay community. The drug cocktail that now allows many to live relatively normal lives was years off. Then the struggle to find treatments for the many diseases of AIDS was literally a battle waged against the government and drug companies. David and a number of his friends were on the front lines of that battle, fighting to survive and fighting so that others might live as part of the controversial activist group ACT UP

David’s personal battle with AIDS was a difficult one marked by many horrific illnesses that ultimately left him blind. When I couldn’t reach him at home I’d call Lenox Hill Hospital (see my rolladex card to the right) to see if he was there.  It was at Lenox Hill 7th floor, the AIDS ward, that he spent his final days. 

With this entry I hope to begin recounting this tale in more detail not so much for the reader’s benefit but for my own.  I miss my dear brother terribly (that’s us together in the header image at the top of this page just behind the word “counting").  His death was a life transforming event. I pray that telling the tale will perhaps complete the transformation.

1. Hi Peter,
   Thank you for sharing David’s story as you write your own. I went to jr and sr high school with David and we were part of the same pack of chorus hounds. Funny to think of this, but within our group he was a “father figure”...imagine that at 14 years old!
   I turned out gay too- as well as a number of us in that group -although at the time it was not something any of us shared if we even knew. He was a large part of why music became such a positive impact on my life and the impact was so strong that years later when things became very difficult and confusing for me, i at least had that thing that could save me and bring the world -even if only for a moment -into balance.  I remember when he got his braces off and could eat pizza with out worrying about getting the cheese all stuck in there. We were very fortunate to have such a close and talented collection of friends and to this day i wish i had better appreciated the rare joy of harmony that i had taken for granted. I must have thought all singers could contribute that way, but i have learned that it takes a generous selfless talent to create a rich harmony. I admired David and am very happy he pursued a life in the arts.
   The Aids epidemic has taken so many of us and impacted all of our lives. Then to have the memory only of a teenager. How sad it all is. I know it was a man that left this world, but i remember the boy.Thanks again for being so generous with your personal memories and thoughts and also thank you for providing the opportunity for others to “harmonize”.
   best wishes,
   Rosaleen Marion

   Posted by  on  08/04  at  05:55 AM

2. Hi Peter… I was searching the net for “news” about David, as I often do around this time of year. Although I carry him deep within my heart, for some inexplicable reason I keep searching cyberspace for word about him. I keep trying to see if I can find a copy of his cable show, or a new mention. Often times nothing new comes up, but today I saw this entry. It is almost 15 years since David’s passing, but the gift of having him in my life remains with me always. Thank you for sharing his story. Love to you all....Eddie

   Posted by  on  11/20  at  09:59 AM

<< Back to main